News – Amazon (accidentally?) allows sale of pedophilia book

Okay so I am a bit late to the game on this one.  Looks like all of the outrage over the following started on Wednesday.  Apparently a Kindle book was put up on Amazon called “The Pedophile’s Guide to Love and Conduct” and of course outrage ensued.  I think it is pretty safe to say the vast majority of us are strongly against pedophilia.  Amazon ended up pulling the book, which took a bit of time because of some of the legal issues they were up against.  You can see the final resolution of the issue here: http://edition.cnn.com/2010/US/11/11/pedophile.guide/?hpt=T2

I just can’t help myself…I have a couple things I need to say about this.  First of all the overwhelming initial sentiment and knee-jerk reaction was for people to start yelling about how they are going to boycott Amazon and will pull all of there reviews etc from Amazon’s site.  Now I don’t know about the rest of you but Amazon has kind of become an intergral part of my life with the Vine program, reviewing, and even running this blog.  Given that Amazon doesn’t screen all of the Kindle books that are published I feel like this is a pretty harsh and stupid reaction…it’s not really going to solve anything.  Unfortunately this whole issue burns down to a more basic question…should Amazon be able to decide what is and isn’t published on their site?

Granted in this case it was dealing with pedophilia, which is probably one of the only issues that 99.999% of the population agree is a horrible thing and shouldn’t be allowed.  But what if this was a more controversial issue?  What if someone wrote a handbook to abortion?  Should Amazon ban sales of that book in states where is abortion is illegal?  Do we really want a large corporate conglomerate telling us what we should and shouldn’t read?  I know I for one don’t want that.  I agree with the comment Amazon returned with which was:

“Let me assure you that Amazon.com does not support or promote hatred or criminal acts; we do support the right of every individual to make their own purchasing decisions.

Amazon.com believes it is censorship not to sell certain titles because we believe their message is objectionable. Therefore, we’ll continue to make controversial works available in the United States and everywhere else, except where they’re prohibited by law. We also allow readers, authors, and publishers to express their views freely about these titles and other products we offer on our website. However, Amazon.com doesn’t endorse opinions expressed by individual authors, musical artists, or filmmakers. “

Darn straight, I don’t want a company deciding what I am reading!  It is absolutely no one’s business what I want to read.  I mean really you could really blow this out of proportion.  Let’s say you are reading a fantasy book in which a child is captured and sold to someone for sexual purposes; not at all far-fetched since I know we have all read this plotline in fantasy before (and probably many other genres).  Should Amazon ban those books too because they promote pedophilia?  Couldn’t you say that reading about these scenarios help to protect against pedophilia as well since they show how to defend you and those you love from this crime?
That being said I totally agree that Amazon should have removed this book.  I do feel that as the publisher for these Kindle books Amazon should have some power deciding what gets published for the Kindle; I mean every publisher has that power.  People should also think about the good that has come out of direct to Kindle publishing.  I have read some really great authors that have published direct to Kindle…if it wasn’t for this new form of publishing I would have never been able to read the stories they have written.
So overall I am conflicted about the whole issue.  I definitely don’t want someone restricting what I can buy.  I also don’t want to support anyone who is practicing pedophilia.  Ultimately the right thing to do would be for no one to buy that stupid handbook; that way the author doesn’t benefit.  But, I think boycotting Amazon is a bit harsh.  Basically consumers want to punish Amazon for being innovative and allowing the every-day-Joe to publish whatever they want to publish.  It just doesn’t make sense.
Maybe this is a good thing and it will allow Amazon to put a better screening process in place for books that are published to Kindle.  Maybe it’s not and we will start seeing restrictions on more of the material that is published to Kindle; restrictions that make it so the buyer will never see material they want to read.  Of course if this happens, as a reader, I will never know what I am missing.
On a side note, there has been comment that this Handbook was actually posted of part of a scheme to catch pedophiles.  If that is the case it just makes things more complicated.
Let me know your thoughts…this is definitely one of those things that isn’t very clear cut.  But, I personally will not be boycotting Amazon.  I don’t see the point.  They have been a great company and provided me with many years of great service.  I love the innovation and risk they have been taking with their direct to Kindle publishing.  I hate to see a great company shot down because of one stupid person doing something incredibly distasteful. 

Written by

Visit my Website Follow me on Twitter

Comments are closed.

Follow

Get every new post on this blog delivered to your Inbox.

Join other followers: