Review – Silver and Lead (October Daye, Book 19) by Seanan McGuire (3.5/5 stars)

Reading Level: Adult
Genre: Urban Fantasy
Length: 393 pages
Publisher: Tor Books
Release Date: September 30, 2025
ASIN: B0DQJ76DMG
Stand Alone or Series: 19th book in the October Daye series
Source: eGalley from NetGalley
Rating: 3.5/5 stars

“Something is rotten in Faerie. In the aftermath of Titania’s reality-warping enchantment, things are returning to what passes for normal in the Kingdom in the Mists—until it’s discovered that the royal vaults have been looted, and several powerful magical artifacts are missing. None are things that can be safely left unsecured, and some have the potential to do almost as much damage as Titania did, and having them in the wrong hands could prove just as disastrous.

At least the theft means that Sir October “Toby” Daye, Knight errant and Hero of the Realm, finally has an excuse to get out of the house. Sure, she’s eight and a half months pregnant, but that doesn’t mean she can’t take care of herself. But with the sea witch offering to stand godmother to Toby’s child, maybe there are greater dangers ahead for Toby and her family than it appears….

Old enemies will resurface, new enemies will disguise themselves as friends, and Queen Windermere must try to keep her Hero on the case without getting herself gutted by the increasingly irritated local King of Cats. Sometimes, what’s been lost can be the most dangerous threat of all.”

Series Info/Source: This is the 19th book in the October Daye series. I got this on ebook through NetGalley for review.

Thoughts: I liked this book better than the last couple books in the series, which isn’t saying much. The previous couple of books have felt like filler. While it still feels like McGuire isn’t quite sure where this series is going, this book does progress the story some. I ended up finishing it even though I skimmed some of the exposition.

Toby is back at home and much more pregnant than she expected to be because of everything that happened in the previous book. Tybalt is driving her a bit crazy with his protectiveness, especially since she still has a couple weeks before her due date. Tybalt and Toby are called to court to testify against Titania. While there, Arden pulls Toby aside to ask for her help; some very dangerous items from the royal vaults are missing…including a Hope Chest. Arden would like Toby to investigate.

I continue to love the world and the characters here. I enjoyed watching our characters find happiness and family amidst all the craziness going on.

However, there was a lot I struggled with here as well. Over half this book is exposition; McGuire spends way too much time recapping and too much time rehashing thoughts in the characters’ heads. While reading this, there were huge sections that I noticed myself skimming through so I could get back to dialogue and characters actually doing things. I felt like this book needed some serious editing; it would have been a better story at half the length.

I also struggled with both everyone’s over-protectiveness of pregnant Toby and with Toby’s irrational decisions. The characters seemed to be making decisions that were very…well…out of character. Even Arden asking Toby to do this investigation this late in Toby’s pregnancy felt weird to me; it was explained away as Toby being the only knight in the realm who could do it. However, given the size of the realm, that makes no sense. It didn’t feel like something Arden would normally do as a character either.

For many, many years, McGuire was a go-to author for me. The last five or so years that has tapered off. I am not sure what changed, me or her as a writer. I feel like no one edits these books and makes sure they are tight and well paced. McGuire’s writing has gotten slower, the pacing more drawn out, and she spends way too much page space on both exposition and re-running thoughts through her characters’ head. Readers are smart; they don’t need this much over-explaining.

There is a nice novella at the end that dives into Simon’s return to the Undersea. It was nice to get some insight into Simon’s thoughts and feelings and get a look at how his new home is treating him.

My Summary (3.5/5): Overall I was happy that this was a bit faster in pace than the last few previous books but still frustrated by how wordy and over-explained things were. For the last four of five books, I have felt like this series is getting tired and needs to be wrapped up. I hope this book is on the way to doing that. I almost didn’t picked this up to read at all, but I have been reading this series forever so decided to give it a chance. I am even more on the fence now about whether I will pick up future books in this series.